Monday, December 3, 2007

Toledo Edison Fails to Turn Electricity On for Family of Nine


updates below

I received a phone call on Friday morning, the day I posted about the fire that killed a mother and her three children who were using candles because Toledo Edison [FirstEnergy] cut their power off. The call was from a Catholic sister who runs a 'community' center in the inner city of Toledo, the Padua Center. She told me of a family nearby whose children come to the center [a former church rectory]. They told her that they have no electricity and no heat in their house and are using candles for light.


My wife and I found out that she was denied any help from Lucas County Children Services, even though she pleaded her case to them. We called some people to get the ball rolling and brought some food and flashlights to them on Saturday. They have one kerosene heater for all 9 people living there. Seven children, their mother and grandmother have been without electricity and their furnace for two weeks. The mother borrowed the money and paid the bill on Friday but Toledo Edison cannot get there until Tuesday, a spokesman for the company told the mother.

A phone call from ABLE/LAWCO could not move Toledo Edison to restore their power in this 30 degree weather. Today's wind-chill is 20 degrees. The family has a small kerosene heater kept in the dining room, sheets attached to the walls to keep that room warm.

What a disgrace this is for FirstEnergy and Toledo Edison.

Where is humanity in the corporate world? Absent, for sure.

update 11:15 AM Tuesday

My wife just talked with the mother and she reports that they are still without electricity. When asked how she was, the mother said. "Cold, very cold!" My wife said that her voice was raspy. I wonder how it was for the children getting off to school this morning, having spent yet another night in a cold, dark house?

update 12:20 PM Tuesday

The story becomes more and more incredible as the hours go by. Both my wife and I were on the phone to Toledo Edison, playing the run-around game. It is not easy to speak to a live person but my wife finally connected with a gentleman who told her that the power was 'on.' She immediately called the mother who said, "No it isn't." Another call back to Toledo Edison, through all of the prompts, to a man named Julius. He said it is 'on' and the mother needs to check for a clear or gray tag on her meter and also to check her circuit breakers. A call to the mother: she checked and found no tag on the meter. My wife handed the phone to me- "Your turn!"

I called the 800 number, through the prompts, got a person and asked for 'Julius.' Music played, I waited and 'Tom' answered. "I was waiting for a representative named Julius, is he there?" "No, he stepped out." "Well, perhaps you could help," I began, "my wife and I have..." "Oh, what was that address?" He checked, "It looks like Julius put in a 'connect' order." "When?" I asked. "About 5 minutes ago," he replied.

I said to Tom, "Listen, Toledo Edison and FirstEnergy Corp already has one burned home and four children on the record and you are playing games with another one and nine people." Not waiting for a reply from him, I told him that I was going to call The Blade and report this to them.

Shortly after that I rang up Laren Weber at The Blade, she is the one who wrote the story of the fire on Lyman Street. I gave her the story and she assured me that she was going to make some phone calls.

What is so incredible about this entire story are the many hurdles that a person like this mother has to jump in trying to resolve the issue. How could she hope to solve this problem herself? It has taken a law department, two fairly-well connected adults and a Blade reporter to move this process, hopefully, forward.

I am going to the home now and will report back later this afternoon.


update 3 PM Tuesday


I met the oldest boy of the family at the Padua Center, a block from his home. He was roaming the halls and his mother had to grab him by the hand to lead him back to the room where is younger siblings, mother, and grandmother were. Apparently he is mentally unstable and although 14-years-old, he would not talk. I, too, grabbed his hand to lead him back and it was as cold as a dead-man's hand. The nun was heating some pizza for them while they warmed up. His mother tried to keep him seated, but the boy yanked free, got up, and walked around as in a daze. Only the pizza led him back to his seat.


After the pizza and the warm-up we walked back to the still-cold house. At 2:30 the Toledo Edison truck pulled up, pulled the meter, threw a switch, and drove off. Power returned to the house after two weeks. What an ordeal. I wonder if the Blade reporter had any influence or if she was just next in line. Only the managers at Edison know that answer. At least tonight, everyone will be warm in their beds at last.

14 comments:

microdot said...

I heard that you had your first snow of the season already.
Did you learn of this from the Toledo News Media?
Obviously, the Toledo Edison doesn't have to care about their image, if you really need electricity, hey, where else you gonna go?
In most Western European countries, it is illegal to cut power during the winter. It is also very hard to evict a tenant iin the winter.
This might lead to some abuses, sure, but it also saves lives.
Good for you and your compassionate action!

mud_rake said...

It is absolutely raw in Toledo and has been for the past 2 days. Winds are steady at 40 mph, occasional snow, and hovering below freezing.

By the way, Toledo Edison's [FirstEnergy] profits for the 3rd quarter were $1.2 billion.

Shysters!

Lisa Renee said...

Goes to show that whole bs line that First Energy stated after the fire was not true as many of us already knew.

They don't care if there are children in the home and there should be something that is done about that in the winter months.

mud_rake said...

Lisa- in fact, the head of ABLE [LAWO]told my wife that he, too, did not believe the story that FirstEnergy gave after the fire in West Toledo.

Isn't it just amazing how lying has become part of the fabric of the corporate world?

steve said...

I don't know why anyone is surprised. Corporations are soulless-consciousless entities whose sole purpose is stockholder investment growth. If it was morally acceptable to pitchfork babies into a depolymorization devise and extract the constituent baby enzymes there would be corporations lining up to do it.

It's the same sort of philosophy at work that allows Dick Cheney as head of Halliburton to petition the Clinton administration to ease sanctions against Libya and Iran so that his company can do business with these “rogue” regimes… but then as Vice President, line up the Carrier battle groups to bomb the bejesus out of them.

That’s why the law enacted in the 1800 under the Supreme Court ruling in Santa Clara County v. Southern Pacific Railroad giving corporations juristic personhood should be re-examined and repealed.

craig said...

Of course lying is part of the corporate fabric. Nobody at the top of the corporate ladder ever suffers the consequences for their actions, so why should they care about who dies or gets hurt? First Energy almost caused a nuclear disaster of epic proportions. Do you think they care about a few families?

microdot said...

Wow, what a tale!

Holly said...

I knew it was a lie the minute the guy from Edison said that on TV! I've personally experienced the "Hand of Edison"! Without any warning and with our bill being paid they came and pulled our electric meter the Monday before Thanksgiving 2 years ago. When I called to find out why I was told that there is an investigation going on because an anonymous person reported that we had been tampering with our meter so that it wouldn't show the full electric that we had been using. I was originally told that the investigation could take up to 6 weeks, during which I had ZERO chance of having my electric restored. It took 2 days worth of phone calls and ended with us agreeing to pay a $750 fine before they would finally agree to turn our power back on, then it took them an additional 30 hours to turn it back on even though they said it would be back on within 6 hours. The temps hovered in the low 20's and teens overnight and we have two children, and it made no difference to them. Did we tamper with our meter? NO! Did they ever admit that they were wrong? Of course not, but we did get a letter about 6 months later that stated the "investigation" had been closed and our meter showed no signs of being tampered with. And that $750? Well, that supposedly covered they expenses for the investigation and we'll never see it.

Edison knows that they hold a monopoly on the electric in the area, they thrive on the fact that they can do what they want to do, when they want to do it and totally get away with it! Unfortunately, until we get a different option for electric, we're screwed and have no choice but to put up with this!

mud_rake said...

Holly- thank you for sharing your story. Your story mirrors that of the mother in my story.

The citizens have absolutely no power over a large corporate momopoly like FirstEnergy. None whatsoever! We are at their mercy, like peasants in the Middle Ages.

Holly said...

Wasn't sure if you'd see this over at Glass City or not or if you had it yourself already, but here is a LINK to PUCO's utility rate comparison for Ohio.

mud_rake said...

Thanks again, holly. I'll zip over there.

By the way, my blog has been 'visited' by FirstEnergyCorp. They did a Google search for "family dies in ohio fire first energy" and my blog was the first hit.

Holly said...

I think they're probably trying to see how many sites have talked about this or how many news stories have been written about it so that they can see how much they need to cover their asses and how much they need to cover up to make it look like they've done no wrong, not only in this case, but in others as well.

I do fully understand that Edison is a for profit company, but when they lie by saying that they try not to cut off power to homes with children to try and make themselves look better in the public eye, something is seriously WRONG! They need to "man up" to what they do and how they treat their customers. And they need to do something to get this area out of the highest ranked electricity cost in the state!

This is really going to make me sound stupid, but why do businesses get a MUCH lower electric rate than residences? We pay almost twice as much for the same electricity that businesses do. Maybe that is common, I honestly know nothing about things like that, so like I said, I'm really making myself look stupid. But I thought maybe someone might know the answer.

Lisa Renee said...

I'm glad their power is finally on, but I can't help wondering how many other families right now are going through the same thing. I think all of us here realize they are out there...

qslimms said...

they shut mine off and said I had to pay 470 then I get a bill two days later saying I owe 1200 so no way I can afford that I cant cook for my kids or keep food unless it is non perishable anyone know of a place that can help please call me at 419 388 6646 or email at qslimms@yahoo.com i can check my emails at the library

Lefty Blogs